About This Blog

Michael Merschel: Michael Merschel edits books coverage for The Dallas Morning News.
Joy Tipping: Joy Tipping is an arts writer and Guide copy editor who occasionally reviews books and author talks.


November 2010
S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

Recent Posts

Categories

GuideLive.com
Entertainment Blogs


Comments  | Recommended

How much would you pay for an Amazon.com review?

10:04 AM Wed, Jun 11, 2008 |  | 
Michael Merschel / Editor    Bio |  E-mail  |  News tips

Local management consultant Joel Zeff is the author of Make the Right Choice: Creating a Positive, Innovative, and Productive Work Life. (Disclosure: He's also a friend from college.)

Two items in his recent newsletter caught my eye:

Joel has an interesting approach for generating attention for his book: He's willing donating $20 to charity for each review posted at Amazon.

Is that ethical?

Joel tells me why he did it:

"Getting people to post Amazon reviews is much like asking people to help you move furniture. It just doesn't happen. Everyone says they enjoyed the book. They love the book. 'Would you mind posting a review on Amazon?' I ask. Everyone says they are going to do it. And then it doesn't happen. I understand we are all very busy. And, posting a review is not on the top of most people's lists.

"So, I thought I would put a little incentive out there. I am not trying to buy my reviews. And I don't want to seem like I am. I just thought a small incentive to a worthy cause might prompt some people to move the "post a review for Joel" to the top of the To Do list."

Frankly, I expect that kind of thing from Amazon reviews. And I think an author can do whatever he wants to promote a book, as long as he's open about it.

The problem I have is with those who would suggest that such material, as some have suggested, can replace the professional book review.

Your thoughts?

The other item that caught my eye: Joel analyzes his appearance on Fox & Friends Weekend. It's a lesson for touring authors in how to be unflappable. As Joel writes:


1. Watch me dart my eyes back and forth at the beginning of the interview. Yes, it is quite scary, but at this point I am thinking, "I am going to have to do this interview with this dude holding a puppy."

2. Count the number of times I say, "you know." Shameful. But all I am thinking about is the puppy. And then when I hold the puppy I am thinking, "Please don't let the puppy do anything on my new suit."

3. Try to answer the question, "Why is Joel holding a puppy?"


Archived Comments

I wouldn't pay anything, but I have offered readers a free book in exchange for posting a review on Amazon. I think that's fair, and gives me something to do with my extra copies. It can be good for sales, but is also good just to gets me feedback from regular people, as opposed to just critics.


Readers can distinguish between professional
reviews and amateur reviews. When I'm considering a book, or especially several on the same
topic, I'd rather see a reviews than none at all. As a writer, I welcome all(ahem-positive)reviews.



TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://dmn.beloblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/114150

Advertisement

THINGS TO DO
Search
Events Restaurants Movies Venues
What
 
When
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
What
 
Price Range
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
Movies
 
When
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
What
 
   
Where
 
Within
  Miles
From GuideLive.com

Books on the Web

Spotlight
Advertisement