About This Blog

Michael Merschel: Michael Merschel edits books coverage for The Dallas Morning News.
Joy Tipping: Joy Tipping is an arts writer and Guide copy editor who occasionally reviews books and author talks.


November 2010
S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

Recent Posts

Categories

GuideLive.com
Entertainment Blogs


Comments  | Recommended

Reviews for Jane Austen fans: "The Independence of Miss Mary Bennett," "Jane Austen Ruined My Life"

10:27 AM Fri, Feb 13, 2009 |  | 
Michael Merschel / Editor    Bio |  E-mail  |  News tips

Travel editor Mary Ellen Botter weighs in on a pair of recent releases aimed at Austenites:

marybennett.jpgAnother take on Jane Austen's "Pride": Austenites are always eager for embroideries on Jane's novels, in particular that romantic home run Pride and Prejudice. A new thread comes from an unexpected source: best-selling author Colleen McCullough (Thornbirds, Masters of Rome series).

Disappointingly, the author crashes through expectations into improbability in The Independence of Miss Mary Bennett (Simon & Schuster, $26). Behavior ingrained (more likely required) in gentlefolk of the Regency era is set aside for more modern themes: feminism, homophobia and religious zealotry.

Mr. Darcy is a loutish lover and a disappointment to Elizabeth. Mary, her younger sister, is a crusader for the downtrodden. A mad monk imprisons Mary in a cave, no less. So un-Jane-like and far-fetched are these themes that it seems that only the characters' names link McCullough's book to Austen's literary legacy. For Austenites, it's a snack, not a feast.

janeaustenruined.jpgA novel close to Jane's heart: Surely Jane would have approved the plot of Jane Austen Ruined My Life by Beth Pattillo (Guideposts, $14.99). The romantic novel follows Austen's well-plumbed story line of love found, love lost and love rediscovered.

Was Jane speaking of her own life, or one she wished for -- or lost?

Emma Grant, a discredited professor and Austen expert, hunts the answer as she chases purported lost letters by the famed novelist. Leading her in the chase is a mysterious group, The Formidables, said to have been created by Jane's beloved sister Cassandra to keep the writer's secrets of the heart, expressed in the 200-years-hidden missives. Faced with the revelation that would salvage her career yet possibly ruin Austen's reputation, Emma wrestles with her own shattered love.

Although a quick read, Ruined isn't shallow. Austen fans will delight in descriptions of real Austen sites in England, honest emotions and the thought that actual discoveries may someday reveal more about the beloved novelist.



TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://dmn.beloblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/155368

Advertisement

THINGS TO DO
Search
Events Restaurants Movies Venues
What
 
When
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
What
 
Price Range
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
Movies
 
When
 
Where
 
Within
  Miles
What
 
   
Where
 
Within
  Miles
From GuideLive.com

Books on the Web

Spotlight
Advertisement